Dirt and Bricks
  • blog
  • about
  • contact

Proposals and Engagements

5/5/2017

1 Comment

 
Picture
I've been thinking a lot recently about boredom, novelty, and student engagement. How can we balance the potential that comes from boredom with the spark and energy that novelty can provide?  How can we maximize student engagement without becoming, as the teachers, totally responsible for it?  

The energy in our classroom lately has been unsettled.  Agitated.  I heard the snippiness in our voices; saw the scattered, abandoned materials; felt the tension and unease in our interactions.  We seemed, to me, a pretty cranky bunch.  And one common thread I kept noticing was how little engagement appeared to be happening, both between the children and the materials and the children with each other.  

When I provided a totally teacher-directed activity, such as a whole group read aloud or game, I noticed that the students were overall attentive and interested.  But when left to choose their own learning, which was the bulk of the day, I saw the students arguing, testing limits, and becoming silly to the point of totally losing control.  I recommitted to holding firm on limits and the expectations determined by the group, which seemed to help a bit.  Then, in a burst of....well, let's not call it "desperation." How about "inspiration?"  Yes.  In a burst of inspiration, I decided to trade out about 3/4 of our materials for new items.  I also switched around some furniture and added new dramatic play props.  Some of those choices had clear intentions and purposes, but many did not.  I simply offered them to mix it up, offer something sheerly for the novelty of it.  

Lo and behold, it was as if I had my old class back!  My class of cheerful, innovative, deeply curious students.  All because, it seems, of some "new stuff."  Would their learning have been richer, more meaningful, if I'd let them grapple with this rough patch without "new stuff" saving the day?  Or does the ensuing peace and productivity better serve the students and their learning?  

How do you determine when to update materials?  How do you view the roles of boredom and novelty in your classroom?
1 Comment
Nina link
5/5/2017 10:26:44 pm

I love this post, it's really got me thinking.
I'm a huge advocate of letting children get bored and I do believe that it can lead to great creativity and engagement. But I wonder if it is helpful to distinguish between boredom resulting from a kind of laziness and failure to work at engaging, and boredom from being done with something, having gone as deep into it as you can for the moment.
We know that novelty is good for us, whether it's new input for babies that extends their development (my own children always seemed to achieve their "firsts" when we were away from home!) or something like travel for adults, experiences that refresh and renew us.
I definitely experience the same thing in my classroom that you described, where the children suddenly seem so unfocused and restless but they can't really articulate the problem themselves. It feels different to the "I'm borrrrrrrrred!" we sometimes hear, and the restlessness does seem to go when they get new input that captures their imaginations.
Thank you for such a thought-provoking post! Your blog is wonderful.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.


    Reggio-inspired teaching, parenting, and living

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.